Prime Factorization Number Notation
I have a mathematical puzzle - an unusual notation for representing numbers. It can represent all rational numbers and a number of irrational (algebraic) numbers as well. Please explain how this notation works; if you think you have a correct explanation, show me how you represent 30000 and 210^(2/5) and I'll confirm whether you have it right.
Here is a list of examples, which were all I needed to solve the puzzle. It will help to think like a mathematician.
1 = []
2 = [[]]
3 = [][[]]
4 = [[[]]]
12 = [[[]]][[]]
0 =
-1 = -[]
19 = [][][][][][][][[]]
20 = [[[]]][][[]]
-2 = -[[]]
1/2 = [-[]]
sqrt(2) = [[-[]]]
72^1/6 = [[-[]]][[][-[]]]
5/4 = [-[[]]][][[]]
84 = [[[]]][[]][][[]]
25/24 = [-[][[]]][-[]][[[]]]
Okay, this is a fascinating puzzle! It strongly resembles a notation based on the prime factorization of numbers, where the structure represents the exponents of successive primes. Let's break it down.
Explanation of the Notation
-
Prime Factorization Basis: The notation represents a number
N
by encoding the exponents in its prime factorization:N = p₁^e₁ * p₂^e₂ * p₃^e₃ * ...
wherep₁=2
,p₂=3
,p₃=5
, etc., are the prime numbers in order. -
Structure: The representation is a sequence of bracketed terms, where the k-th term in the sequence specifies the exponent
eₖ
for the k-th primepₖ
. -
Encoding Exponents:
- The exponent
eₖ
itself is a number, and it is represented using the same notation system recursively. Let's call the representation of a numberx
asRep(x)
. - The term for the k-th prime
pₖ
with exponenteₖ
is[Rep(eₖ)]
.
- The exponent
-
Zero Exponent: If a prime
pₖ
is not a factor of the number (i.e.,eₖ = 0
), its corresponding term is omitted unless it's needed as a placeholder between primes that are present. The representation of the exponent 0 is the empty string ``. The representation of 1 (the multiplicative identity, often corresponding to exponent 0 in some contexts, but here used for exponent 1) is[]
. When an exponenteₖ
is 0, its term[Rep(0)] = []
effectively acts as a skip or placeholder.- Example:
3 = p₂¹ = p₁⁰ * p₂¹
. Exponent for p₁ is 0 (Rep(0)
is empty, term is[]
), exponent for p₂ is 1 (Rep(1) = []
, term is[[]]
). Combined:[] [[]]
. This matches the example[][[]]
. - Example:
5 = p₃¹ = p₁⁰ * p₂⁰ * p₃¹
.[] [] [[]]
.
- Example:
-
Concatenation: The full representation of
N
is the concatenation of the terms[Rep(e₁)] [Rep(e₂)] ... [Rep(eₖ)]
, wherepₖ
is the largest prime factor ofN
. Trailing[]
terms (for primes with exponent 0 beyond the largest factor) are omitted. -
Base Cases:
1 = []
(This represents the number 1, which has all prime exponents equal to 0. It also serves as the representation for the exponent 1).0 =
(The empty string represents the number 0).
-
Negation: A leading hyphen
-
negates the number represented by the following expression.-1 = -[]
-2 = -[[]]
-
Fractions and Irrational Numbers: Negative and fractional exponents are handled naturally by representing the exponent accordingly.
1/2 = 2⁻¹ = p₁⁻¹
. The exponent is -1.Rep(-1) = -[]
. The term for p₁ is[-[]]
. This matches.sqrt(2) = 2¹ᐟ² = p₁¹ᐟ²
. The exponent is 1/2.Rep(1/2) = [-[]]
. The term for p₁ is[[-[]]]
. This matches.5/4 = 5 * 4⁻¹ = 5 * (2²)⁻¹ = 5 * 2⁻² = p₃¹ * p₁⁻²
. Sorted by prime:p₁⁻² * p₃¹
.- e₁ = -2.
Rep(-2) = -[[]]
. Term:[-[[]]]
. - e₂ = 0. Term:
[]
. - e₃ = 1.
Rep(1) = []
. Term:[[]]
. - Combined:
[-[[]]] [] [[]]
. This matches the example[-[[]]][][[]]
. (The middle[]
acts as the placeholder for p₂=3).
- e₁ = -2.
25/24 = 25 * 24⁻¹ = 5² * (8*3)⁻¹ = 5² * (2³ * 3¹)⁻¹ = 5² * 2⁻³ * 3⁻¹ = p₃² * p₁⁻³ * p₂⁻¹
. Sorted by prime:p₁⁻³ * p₂⁻¹ * p₃²
.- e₁ = -3.
Rep(3) = [][[]]
.Rep(-3) = -[][[]]
. Term:[-[][[]]]
. - e₂ = -1.
Rep(-1) = -[]
. Term:[-[]]
. - e₃ = 2.
Rep(2) = [[]]
. Term:[[[]]]
. - Combined:
[-[][[]]] [-[]] [[[]]]
. This matches.
- e₁ = -3.
-
Potential Discrepancy: The example
72^(1/6) = [[-[]]][[][-[]]]
seems inconsistent.72^(1/6) = (2³ * 3²)^(1/6) = 2^(3/6) * 3^(2/6) = 2^(1/2) * 3^(1/3) = p₁^(1/2) * p₂^(1/3)
.- e₁ = 1/2.
Rep(1/2) = [-[]]
. Term:[[-[]]]
. - e₂ = 1/3.
Rep(1/3) = Rep(3⁻¹) = Rep(p₂⁻¹)
. Exponent for p₂ is -1.Rep(-1) = -[]
. So,Rep(1/3) = [] [-[]]
. Term for p₂:[ [] [-[]] ]
. - Combined representation should be
[[-[]]] [ [] [-[]] ]
. - The example given is
[[ -[] ]] [ [] [-[]] ]
. Oh, wait, my derivation exactly matches the example this time! I must have made a mistake in my previous thought process. Let's re-traceRep(1/3)
:1/3 = 3⁻¹ = p₂⁻¹
.- Exponent for p₁ is 0. Term
[]
. - Exponent for p₂ is -1.
Rep(-1) = -[]
. Term[-[]]
. - Concatenate:
[] [-[]]
. This isRep(1/3)
. - The term for
p₂^(1/3)
is[ Rep(1/3) ] = [ [] [-[]] ]
. This matches the second part of the example. - The term for
p₁^(1/2)
is[ Rep(1/2) ] = [ [-[]] ]
. This matches the first part.
- Okay, the system is consistent across all examples.
Representing Your Numbers
Based on this understanding:
-
Represent 30,000:
- Prime Factorization:
30000 = 3 * 10⁴ = 3 * (2*5)⁴ = 2⁴ * 3¹ * 5⁴ = p₁⁴ * p₂¹ * p₃⁴
. - e₁ = 4.
Rep(4) = Rep(2²) = Rep(p₁²)
. Exponent for p₁ is 2.Rep(2) = [[]]
. SoRep(4) = [[[]]]
. Term:[[[[]]]]
- e₂ = 1.
Rep(1) = []
. Term:[[]]
- e₃ = 4.
Rep(4) = [[[]]]
. Term:[[[[]]]]
- Concatenate:
[[[[]]]] [[]] [[[[]]]]
- Prime Factorization:
-
Represent 210^(2/5):
- Base Prime Factorization:
210 = 2 * 3 * 5 * 7 = p₁¹ * p₂¹ * p₃¹ * p₄¹
. - Apply Exponent:
210^(2/5) = (p₁ * p₂ * p₃ * p₄)^(2/5) = p₁^(2/5) * p₂^(2/5) * p₃^(2/5) * p₄^(2/5)
. - All exponents
e = 2/5
. We needRep(2/5)
. 2/5 = 2 * 5⁻¹ = p₁¹ * p₃⁻¹
.- Exponent for p₁ (within 2/5 representation) is 1.
Rep(1)=[]
. Term[[]]
. - Exponent for p₂ (within 2/5 representation) is 0. Term
[]
. - Exponent for p₃ (within 2/5 representation) is -1.
Rep(-1)=-[]
. Term[-[]]
. - So,
Rep(2/5) = [[]] [] [-[]]
.
- Exponent for p₁ (within 2/5 representation) is 1.
- Now apply this exponent representation to each prime factor p₁, p₂, p₃, p₄ of the main number:
- Term for p₁:
[ Rep(2/5) ] = [ [[]] [] [-[]] ]
- Term for p₂:
[ Rep(2/5) ] = [ [[]] [] [-[]] ]
- Term for p₃:
[ Rep(2/5) ] = [ [[]] [] [-[]] ]
- Term for p₄:
[ Rep(2/5) ] = [ [[]] [] [-[]] ]
- Term for p₁:
- Concatenate:
[ [[]] [] [-[]] ] [ [[]] [] [-[]] ] [ [[]] [] [-[]] ] [ [[]] [] [-[]] ]
- Base Prime Factorization:
Let me know if these representations match your solution! This is a very elegant recursive system based on prime factorization.
Gemini may display inaccurate info, including about people, so double-check its responses.